UER Mobile Forum UER Mobile - Not logged in
Home  Search   User Search   Login  Register  
Messages   New Posts   Favourites   Recent Posts   Recent Views   My LDB   My Buddies  

< (1)[2]
UER Mobile > UE Photo Critiques > Welcome to Photo Critiques (Viewed 48585 times)

post by Obscura   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 20 on 11/26/2005 6:34 PM >

Posted by fatLouie
I think something needs to be established -

This is not a place to compliment without critique. Unless you can say something that is critical of someone's work, don't post. That's what the regular photo board is for - attracting hordes of "OOOOh you are the greatest!" people.

Someone back me up.


I agree... I'm not going to post "that sucks and get a new hobby" but try and offer some tip that might help. It's my opinion though so what does it matter?


Reply with Quote


post by nd31   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 21 on 11/26/2005 7:30 PM >

Posted by fatLouie
I think something needs to be established -

This is not a place to compliment without critique. Unless you can say something that is critical of someone's work, don't post. That's what the regular photo board is for - attracting hordes of "OOOOh you are the greatest!" people.

Someone back me up.


Exactly.

You can still admire someone's work, and you can still post without negative feedback, but the point is feedback beyond a typical "crotch patting" I suppose.
However, I think some of the regular posters who are amazing photographers will not receive much negative feedback, and that is because they do not really deserve it. Nonetheless, they are still open to it.


Reply with Quote


post by Kelwyn   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 22 on 11/26/2005 7:36 PM >

Glad to see this section come up. Looking forward to getting my crap ripped apart.

- Kel


Reply with Quote


post by Louie   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 23 on 11/26/2005 9:19 PM >

Posted by ndillon31

However, I think some of the regular posters who are amazing photographers will not receive much negative feedback, and that is because they do not really deserve it. Nonetheless, they are still open to it.


Yeah, but I'm still waiting to see posts from Mr. Motts, Nicksan, robdobi, thelean... the regulars.





Reply with Quote


post by Glass   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 24 on 11/27/2005 6:02 PM >

Ok I have a little crazy idea coming... it's a little alien BUT WORK WITH ME!!



People should post their honest opinion WHATEVER THAT MAY BE.


---glad I got that out of my system.


Reply with Quote


post by ian_evil   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 25 on 11/27/2005 7:42 PM >

If people post their tourist pics and photo documentation in the main forum, and their artistic photos in this forum, what's the point of the photography forum?


Reply with Quote


post by ednothing   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 26 on 11/27/2005 9:12 PM >

The UE Photography Board:


discussions related to photography, and photos related to UE


This one:

the place to post your art photos and have others critique them





I guess

[last edit 11/27/2005 9:13 PM by ednothing - edited 1 times]

Reply with Quote


post by mada   |  | Noble Donor

Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 27 on 11/28/2005 2:46 AM >

Posted by H5N1
The UE Photography Board:


discussions related to photography, and photos related to UE


This one:

the place to post your art photos and have others critique them





I guess


There's a lot of gray in there.


Reply with Quote


post by DjMalign   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 28 on 11/28/2005 3:36 AM >

Nice. So Mike D has a hissy fit and new rules are set. Its awesome how much power he has for someone who was banned twice


Reply with Quote


post by ednothing   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 29 on 11/28/2005 12:51 PM >

Posted by DjMalign
Nice. So Mike D has a hissy fit and new rules are set. Its awesome how much power he has for someone who was banned twice


I think it had more to do with these threads:

link

link

[last edit 11/28/2005 12:52 PM by ednothing - edited 1 times]

Reply with Quote


post by Azrael   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 30 on 11/29/2005 10:55 AM >

What if someone posts a load of macro or black and white shots and we don't tend to like those shots. do i post: -

A) I don't like macro/black and white shots
Don't post


Reply with Quote


post by nd31   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 31 on 11/29/2005 9:45 PM >

Posted by Azrael
What if someone posts a load of macro or black and white shots and we don't tend to like those shots. do i post: -

A) I don't like macro/black and white shots
Don't post


Ergh... that's not a critique. That's a personal opinion about the shots. You can dislike something and still provide constructive criticism beyond "I don't like it."


Reply with Quote


post by prometheus   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 32 on 7/18/2006 8:50 PM >

This has probably been one of the best features of UER for me. I love posting pictures and learning more about the art of photography from the, so called, "elitists". This has helped me hone my artistic skills a lot, appreciate it for what its worth.


Reply with Quote



Reply
< (1)[2]


This thread is in a public category, and can't be made private.



62 ms gen time