UER Mobile Forum UER Mobile - Not logged in
Home  Search   User Search   Login  Register  
Messages   New Posts   Favourites   Recent Posts   Recent Views   My LDB   My Buddies  

[1](2)>
UER Mobile > UE Photo Critiques > Welcome to Photo Critiques (Viewed 46455 times)

post by Avatar-X   |  | Alpha Husky

Welcome to Photo Critiques
< on 11/25/2005 9:48 PM >

This section is now the place to post your art photos and have others critique them.

Do not post something if you can't take heavy criticism.

Please be civil, however.

-av


Reply with Quote


post by nd31   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 1 on 11/25/2005 9:50 PM >

You rock. Thanks.


Reply with Quote


post by Smash Adams   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 2 on 11/25/2005 9:57 PM >

Good idea. I'll try it out.


Reply with Quote


post by mada   |  | Noble Donor

Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 3 on 11/25/2005 10:53 PM >

You've got to be kidding me, right?

Talk about overkill.

So is it know against the rules to critique a photo posted in the photography forum?

[last edit 11/25/2005 10:57 PM by mada - edited 1 times]

Reply with Quote


post by nd31   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 4 on 11/25/2005 11:00 PM >

Posted by mada
You've got to be kidding me, right?

Talk about overkill.

So is it know against the rules to critique a photo posted in the photography forum?


It's because people who were giving their opinion were being labelled "elitists." Yeah.




Reply with Quote


post by mada   |  | Noble Donor

Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 5 on 11/25/2005 11:02 PM >


It looked to me like a bunch of sniffling vaginas. Funny? Yes. But reason enough for a new forum? No.


Reply with Quote


post by nd31   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 6 on 11/25/2005 11:16 PM >

Posted by mada

It looked to me like a bunch of sniffling vaginas. Funny? Yes. But reason enough for a new forum? No.


Well, I suppose the debate is over as for now. I completely support it since hopefully it will reduce significantly the number of topics that were going in that "sniffling vagina" direction.


Reply with Quote


post by manitou   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 7 on 11/25/2005 11:50 PM >

Excellent Av, thanks!


Reply with Quote


post by Jester   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 8 on 11/26/2005 12:18 AM >

Posted by mada

It looked to me like a bunch of sniffling vaginas. Funny? Yes. But reason enough for a new forum? No.


why bitch ?

This is the place for people that want to be told honestly how bad their photography is. So get in there and make some people feel bad. YAY.


Reply with Quote


post by mada   |  | Noble Donor

Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 9 on 11/26/2005 1:03 AM >

Posted by Jester


why bitch ?

This is the place for people that want to be told honestly how bad their photography is. So get in there and make some people feel bad. YAY.


Good point. The gloves are off.


Reply with Quote


post by Mike Dijital   |  | UEDB Moderator

Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 10 on 11/26/2005 2:19 AM >

I think this is a good idea.


Now no one can bitch.






Reply with Quote


post by Louie   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 11 on 11/26/2005 3:02 AM >

Posted by Mike Dijital
I think this is a good idea.

Now no one can bitch.



Except those of us who want to bitch about how freaking bad some people are at taking photos.


Reply with Quote


post by GotPaisley!   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 12 on 11/26/2005 3:58 AM >

I know I won't be posting any of my pictures in this thread. = )

[last edit 11/26/2005 4:04 AM by GotPaisley! - edited 1 times]

Reply with Quote


post by Redknight   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 13 on 11/26/2005 4:22 AM >

Might wanna sticky something along the lines of your first post av.


So is it know against the rules to critique a photo posted in the photography forum?


Wouldnt think so, but you may be called rude or an ass by people who are offended/hurt by your remarks.


Reply with Quote


post by Explorer Zero   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 14 on 11/26/2005 4:37 AM >

this should be interesting...

who will post here? and who will post, over there? and will they post over there because they cant handle heavy criticism and will they still get all those "great pics I like #5 the best" comments here?

I'll post my next batch here thanks Av.


Reply with Quote


post by Redknight   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 15 on 11/26/2005 4:52 AM >

Posted by 2Xtreme
this should be interesting...

who will post here? and who will post, over there? and will they post over there because they cant handle heavy criticism and will they still get all those "great pics I like #5 the best" comments here?

I'll post my next batch here thanks Av.


Ill post in both , but Ill only critique in here.


Reply with Quote


post by aDeLtRiTuS   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 16 on 11/26/2005 5:02 AM >

i dont take my photos for arts sake,i take them for my sake.i dont really care what people think of them artisticly,i take them to show where ive been.i have posted lots of pics on this site and never had bad critisism,i always get the impression that most people are glad to look at new pics of new places and if the photos are of bad quality people are more than helpfull to help you out.i feel this is creating an elitist level.


Reply with Quote


post by Louie   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 17 on 11/26/2005 7:23 AM >

I think something needs to be established -

This is not a place to compliment without critique. Unless you can say something that is critical of someone's work, don't post. That's what the regular photo board is for - attracting hordes of "OOOOh you are the greatest!" people.

Someone back me up.


Reply with Quote


post by Explorer Zero   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 18 on 11/26/2005 1:45 PM >

Posted by fatLouie
I think something needs to be established -

This is not a place to compliment without critique. Unless you can say something that is critical of someone's work, don't post. That's what the regular photo board is for - attracting hordes of "OOOOh you are the greatest!" people.

Someone back me up.


does the critique always have to be negative? surely reinforcing the shots that do work or came out well provides as much value as pointing out the flaws? or maybe not, I learn from both I think but your point is well taken it should not be about gratuitous praise




Reply with Quote


post by seicer   |  | 
Re: Welcome to Photo Critiques
<Reply # 19 on 11/26/2005 4:39 PM >

If the comments stay constructive and on-topic, then UE Photo Critiques will be a nice asset. From what I've read and commented on so far, it seems pretty promising.


Reply with Quote



Reply
[1](2)>


This thread is in a public category, and can't be made private.



93 ms gen time