|
Notes for posters:
a) No more than 6 photos per critique thread.
b) Titles are better than no titles. If there is no title there must be a number attached to the photograph.
c) Always say what camera you're shooting with and what film (if applicable) with more technical information appreciated on a photo-by-photo basis.
d) Take what people say to you and do with it what you want, but don't get into -another- flame war over negative comments. People don't critique to start fights; it's for your own damn good!
e) All photos posted should be no wider then 700 pixels and no higher than 500 pixels. [Also, a dpi/ppi of 72 would be best for everyone.]
That's all I have... add to this as you wish.
-Glassius
|
|
Great idea.
A general observation would be the less images you have in the thread the more likely you'll get some input.
|
|
Splendid.
>_> |
|
Numbers or titles are fantastic. I hate having to count them up.
|
|
Glass's signature-
I nominate Glass for Photo Critique Mod!
Great ideas. I've thought for a while that some organization to the photo critique board would be a great thing. I thought there needs to be a little consistency to photo sizes, naming and/or numbering, and how many photos are posted, all of which Glass pointed out.
|
|
I think I'd be a difficult mod... but I wouldn't mind a mod coming along and making this topic sticky.
Glass
|
|
What if I post a link to a thumbnail?
YEAHBUTWAT |
|
I would say take it up with the mods in charge of this area:
UE Photo critique
Mutt
Detroit
Shane
WTF indeed. |
|
Posted by nightbird
I would say take it up with the mods in charge of this area:
UE Photo critique
Mutt
Detroit
Shane
|
I'm not taking anything up with anyone.
This forum is all but mod-free (as it should be, I think) and the existing welcome-to-critique was unread and severely lacking. I've had a lot of positive response to my guidelines and I've seen a large positive change for the users in this section.
What's to argue about? Let's give some constructive feedback.
Glassius
EDIT:
PS;
Thanks to the mod who made this sticky (I'm guesing that was NB )!
[last edit 5/20/2006 9:59 PM by Glass - edited 2 times]
|
|
Posted by Corporal_Clegg
What if I post a link to a thumbnail?
|
I see what you've done and it works great: The user has the option of screening them, you kept the photo number low, and the full size image is very large, adding a lot to the presentation.
The only caution I have for you is there is the chance of the photo being stolen because of it's hi-res nature. Use your own judgement.
|
|
| The only caution I have for you is there is the chance of the photo being stolen because of it's hi-res nature. Use your own judgement. |
Me confused.....Please explain.
You can right click-save any photo on this site, so what exactly do you mean?
YEAHBUTWAT |
|
a high resolution photo can be printed into big images. you can use that pic and claim that its yours and then use it to make profit over someones back.
|
|
Ah! Thats what you mean, thanks!
YEAHBUTWAT |
|
Posted by DelbertGrady
I nominate Glass for Photo Critique Mod!
|
haha
I nominate Glass for Being Allowed Back on UER....
|
|
Posted by Leviathan
haha
I nominate Glass for Being Allowed Back on UER....
|
I second that motion!
www.flickr.com/photos/brokenobelisk |
|
I'm confused.
A mod got banned?
i have never taken a photograph in my life
exploring should be done at home, where it's safe |
|
Hahaha, the end of this thread is pretty funny. Glass commenting on Glass being banned.
Leave only footprints, take only pictures... unless its like really cool. |
|
Posted by prometheus
Hahaha, the end of this thread is pretty funny. Glass commenting on Glass being banned.
|
I'm glad someone else thinks it was funny!
|
|
Might I also suggest that the photos be UE-related?
|
|
I'd like to add to this... And I think I made this mistake myself, so I'm not trying to be hypocritical here.. If you have a lot of photos from one place, post a few in one thread and then post more in another one later, not in a reply.. That makes it easier to look at. If they're edits of the same ones, then post in a reply to the original, but if they're new, post a new thread.
|
Ethics
